I’m bummed out. I was really excited to read Age of Bronze Vol 1 & 2, but I couldn’t get into it. I’m well versed in Greek mythology and Eric Shanower’s take on the Trojan War is so different that I spend more time thinking “That’s not right” than simply accepting this is HIS version of the war.
I first read “The Iliad” and “The Odyssey” in third grade. It was the same year that I first read “The Hobbit” and the “Lord of the Rings” trilogy. So it was a BIG year for me and only further validated my love for the fantasy genre.
Since then I’ve read tons of Greek plays and myths for fun as well as in literature classes. I also took mythology classes in high school and college. …because I’ve read translations of the classic stories I have my own interpretations of how Greek mythology works.
For example, one of the first things I noticed in “Age of Bronze” is that the Greek Gods are missing! The gods are major characters in the “Iliad.” You see them as flesh in blood manipulating each other and humans on the battle field and behind the scenes. So it’s very hard for me to accept a re-visioning of the Trojan War without the gods. I mean come one… didn’t we see that in Brad Pitt’s “Troy” and didn’t it SUCK?
In the afterward of Vol. 1 of “Age of Bronze,” Shanower comments on this by saying, “I’ve chosen to downplay the supernatural element in order to emphasize the human element. The only fantastic details I’ve retained are dreams and visions. And when you think about it, these aren’t necessarily as supernatural as they might first appear… but no gods in the flesh.”
Let me try to put this in more present-day terms. A lot of geeks and non-geeks revere the “Star Wars” movies. Its how a lot of people in literature look back at things like the Greek plays or the “Iliad” and “Odyssey.” So… if “Star Wars” was old enough that it was in the public domain and anyone could do anything they wanted with the characters, how do you think people would react to having it revisioned with everything “force” related (supernatural stuff) taken out of it? ——-see! That’s why I can’t read these books.
And don’t get me wrong, it’s not JUST the “god stuff” that Shanower has changed. He has people that should be kings being shown as cow herders. With some characters he has them acting completely different than they do in any piece of literature.
There is nothing wrong with Shanower writing about his version of the Trojan War, but it’s so far from how I see it that I just cannot read his books.